SEO Agency Reporting Checklist: What a Monthly Report Should Prove

Last updated: November 5, 2026

A monthly SEO report should prove three things: where your target keywords rank in the country or city you sell in, which of the links the agency built are actually in Google's index, and whether Google's AI Overviews cite your site. Traffic charts and task lists are useful context, but without these three proofs you are paying for activity, not for evidence.

This checklist is for business owners who already work with an agency, or are choosing one (see our main guide on how to choose the best SEO company and links indexing service). Use it to ask for the right data and to spot-check it yourself.

Key points:

The Three Proofs at a Glance

What the report claims Evidence to ask for How to check it yourself
"Rankings improved" Position per keyword, location, device and date, with the ranking URL Run the same keyword list in a rank tracker set to the same location and device
"We built 40 links" A list of link URLs with index status and check date Paste the URLs into a bulk Google index checker
"We are visible in AI search" Keywords that show an AI Overview, and whether your site is cited Check the same keywords with a tracker that records AI Overview citations

Proof 1: Keyword Positions by Country, City and Device

Google results differ by location and device, so a position without that context means little. A local dentist cares about results in one city; an online store may care about three countries. Ask the agency to fix, in writing, the keyword list, the locations, the device and the check depth, and to keep them the same from month to month so the numbers are comparable.

Search Console is not a substitute. Google's own Performance report documentation describes average position as the average of the topmost result from your site across the queries where it appeared. That blends countries, devices and long-tail queries together. It is good for spotting trends, not for proving that "dental implants Hanoi" moved from 14 to 6.

What a good positions table includes:

To spot-check without a subscription, you can use the SpeedyIndex Google rank tracker. It checks Google desktop results for a country or city you choose, at Top-10, 30, 50 or 100 depth, with up to 10 competitor domains per project. One keyword at Top-10 depth costs 4 tokens (2 tokens until December 2, 2026), and deeper result pages are loaded and billed only while your site or a competitor has not been found yet. With the $5 Start pack of 5,000 tokens, that is about $0.004 per keyword check at the regular rate. Note the limits: it covers Google desktop only, so if your customers search mainly on mobile, ask the agency for mobile data separately.

Link building is often the largest line in an SEO invoice and the hardest one to verify. A link sitting on a page that Google has never indexed gives the report no evidence that Google has processed it at all. That is why "links built: 40" is not a result. "Links built: 40, indexed in Google as of November 3: 31, list attached" is.

Ask for a spreadsheet with these columns: the page URL that carries the link, the target URL on your site, the anchor text, the date the link went live, and the index status with the date of the check. Then spot-check it. The SpeedyIndex Google Index Checker works in bulk and on pages you do not own, which is exactly the case with backlinks. It confirms status with several Google queries, including site: and the exact URL in quotes, and also has a REST API if you want to automate monthly checks. The $5 Start pack covers 1,666 checks.

If a large share of links stays unindexed for weeks, ask the agency why. Common answers are thin or spammy host pages, pages blocked by noindex or robots.txt, or pages that simply have no internal links pointing to them.

Proof 3: AI Overview Citations

AI Overviews now sit above the classic results for many informational queries. According to Google's documentation on AI features and your website, a page must be indexed and eligible to be shown with a snippet to appear as a supporting link, and there are no extra technical requirements or special optimizations. Clicks from AI features are counted inside the normal Search Console Performance report under the "Web" search type, so they are not shown as a separate line.

This means a report should do two simple things: list which tracked keywords trigger an AI Overview in your target location, and state whether your site is cited in it this month. Be wary of any agency that promises AI Overview placements. Google gives no way to guarantee them.

The Monthly Report Checklist

  1. The fixed keyword list, with location, device and check depth stated.
  2. Positions for this month and last month, with the ranking URL.
  3. Competitor positions for the same keywords.
  4. Keywords that show an AI Overview, and whether your site is cited.
  5. Every link built this month: host URL, target URL, anchor, live date.
  6. Index status of each link, with the date of the check.
  7. Status of links built in previous months that were not indexed yet.
  8. Pages on your own site that are still not indexed, from the Search Console page indexing report.
  9. Search Console clicks and impressions for the target pages, as context.
  10. What will be done next month, tied to the gaps above.

Red Flags in Agency Reports

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is the average position in Google Search Console enough for a client report?

No. Search Console averages positions across every query, country and device where your site appeared. It is useful context, but a report should also show fixed target keywords checked in the client's country or city, on the same device and at the same depth every month.

Why should a report show whether built links are indexed?

If the page that carries a link is not in Google's index, the report has no evidence that Google has processed that page. Listing each link URL with its index status and check date lets the client see what was actually delivered.

Can an agency guarantee AI Overview citations?

No. Google says there are no special requirements or optimizations for AI Overviews beyond being indexed and eligible to show with a snippet. A report can track whether the site is cited for the tracked keywords, but it cannot promise citations.

Ask for these three proofs before the next invoice. A good agency will have the data already; a weak one will start explaining why it is not possible.